Most AI projects don't fail because the model is weak. They fail because the use case was wrong from the start. Before I greenlight anything, I run it through three filters.
1. Does it solve a real problem, or just show off the technology?
Most bad use cases exist to demonstrate what AI can do, not to fix something. The test is simple: name the specific step in someone's day that this makes better. If you can't, it isn't ready. “We should use AI here” is not a problem statement. “Underwriters spend two hours a day reading submissions before they can even start pricing” is.
2. Does the work suit the tool, and will people adopt it?
Three questions. Does the AI have the information it needs to do the job? Is the task free of judgment calls that should stay with a person? Does it hand the user something they can act on without redoing the work themselves?
You can have a clean ROI case on paper and still go nowhere. A good use case takes something off someone's plate in a way they can feel. A bad one trims cost on the P&L but adds steps for the person doing the work, and that is usually where adoption dies. The wins handle the work nobody wanted in the first place: checking a policy against a binder, renewal prep, submission intake. The ones that fail still need an expert to go back and redo most of it.
3. Can it earn trust?
In insurance this part is non-negotiable, and the same holds anywhere accuracy has to be right before people will rely on it. For work like policy checking, underwriting triage, or claims intake, the tool has to run alongside the manual process for a while before you retire the old way. The projects that skip this step fail, not because the tool was wrong, but because nobody used it long enough to find out.
The short version
A good use case solves a named problem, fits the work, and earns trust by running in parallel before it replaces anything. A bad one looks impressive in a demo and adds work for the person who has to live with it. The difference shows up long before you write a line of code.
